Get to know » Students » Life and environment:
Caregiver support
Another crucial factor that the PILNA student assessment captured was caregiver support for students. Caregiver support, in its many forms, is widely recognised as an enabler of success in children’s education.
Students from PILNA 2021 were provided with a list of activities and asked to indicate how frequently someone they lived with provided help or support with the activities. They could respond with ‘Always’, ‘Most of the time’, ‘Sometimes’, or ‘Never’.
Caregiver support by proportion of students
Table STT1.7 shows the proportion of students in both year four and year six who answered with either ‘Always’ or ‘Most of the time’.
The results show that about one out of three students reported that their caregivers ‘Always’ or ‘Most of the time’ checked their homework was complete (year four, 35%; year six, 33%), helped with their homework (year four, 40%; year six, 32%), or asked about their schoolwork (year four, 34%; year six, 36%). These ratings about homework and schoolwork were generally lower in Small Island States than in the region.
Half or more of the students reported that their caregivers supported or encouraged them (year four, 49%; year six, 54%), and gave them advice and guidance (year four, 57%; year six, 64%).
Across both year levels, only about one out of four students reported that their caregivers ‘Always’ or ‘Most of the time’ understood their problems and worries (year four, 25%; year six, 26%) or comforted them when they were feeling upset (year four, 29%; year six, 29%). This may be an area to monitor, as these questions may be linked with student well-being.
Caregiver support and student performance
From the responses to the questions about caregiver support (Table STT1.7), a regional scale was developed. This scale was designed to measure the level of caregiver support being offered to students. High scores on this scale represent a greater level of caregiver support than low scores.
Scores for caregiver support were compared for two groups at both the year group levels and in numeracy and reading: for students who were at or above the expected proficiency level and students who were below the expected proficiency level in the cognitive domain. The results of these comparisons are set out in Figure STF1.2.
The PILNA scale for caregiver support has an average of 200 and a standard deviation of 40. Most scores are expected to be within 40 points of 200 (160–240). It was formed using statistical analysis of eight answers to questions that students were asked about their caregiver’s support.
Numeracy
Year 4
- 195 4.2
- 212 1.6
Year 6
- 192 3.3
- 214 1.9
Reading
Year 4
- 200 2.7
- 213 1.8
Year 6
- 201 6.7
- 211 1.5
- Scale score for students below expected proficiency level
- Scale score for students at or above expected proficiency level
- Statistically significant correlation (p <0.05)
- Standard errors appear in parentheses
The results show that, for both year levels and in both numeracy and reading, students who performed at or above the expected proficiency level scored higher on the caregiver support scale.
What does this mean?
Consistent with findings from the previous PILNA cycle, we have seen high levels of caregiver support for students. About one out of three students in Small Island States frequently receive support from their caregivers with homework and about half regularly receive guidance, support, and encouragement. Lower proportions of students, however, frequently felt that their caregivers understood their issues or had their caregivers comfort them when they were upset. These statistics might point towards a disconnect between students and caregivers, although high proportions of students are frequently supported by their caregivers.
There is evidence that support from caregivers is associated with students’ performance in numeracy and reading at both year levels. Students who met performance expectations in these areas had higher levels of caregiver support.
