Get to know » Teachers » Self-reflection:
Teacher confidence in teaching
Teachers were asked two sets of questions about their confidence in teaching: one set for literacy topics and the other for numeracy topics. The questions were phrased as: ‘How do you find teaching the following aspects of literacy/numeracy?’. Their response options were limited to a four-point scale: ‘Very difficult’, ‘Difficult’, ‘Easy’, and ‘Very easy’.
Confidence in teaching literacy
For reporting purposes, teachers who responded with ‘Easy’ or ‘Very easy’ were considered to demonstrate confidence in teaching a particular topic.
Table TT2.7 shows the percentage of students in Papua New Guinea whose teacher expressed confidence in teaching literacy topics.
Overall, most students in both grade levels had teachers who were confident in teaching literacy topics. In both grade levels, the proportions of students with such teachers ranged from 64% to 95%.
Across both grade levels, areas where a lower proportion of students had teachers who expressed confidence were: phonemic awareness (grade three, 64%; grade five, 68%), letter and sound correspondence (grade three, 70%; grade five, 77%), quality of ideas (grade three, 71%; grade five, 78%), and organisation and structure (grade three, 72%; grade five, 81%).
Areas with the highest proportions of students having teachers who expressed confidence were spelling and punctuation (grade three, 94%; grade five, 95%); vocabulary (grade three, 89%; grade five, 94%); reading comprehension (grade three, 89%; grade five, 94%); grammar and syntax (grade three, 89%; grade five, 91%); and oral language (grade three, 86%; grade five, 95%).
Areas where more students had confident teachers appear to be rules-based subjects or those with more established teaching criteria, such as spelling, punctuation, grammar and vocabulary. Areas where fewer students had confident teachers appear to be in areas with more subjective, or more complex, teaching and assessment criteria, such as quality of ideas and organisation and structure in writing.
The same questions were asked of teachers in the 2018 PILNA cycle and results from both the 2018 and 2021 cycles of PILNA are presented here for comparison in Table TT2.8
Compared with the 2018 PILNA cycle, more students in 2021 had teachers who expressed confidence in teaching literacy across all areas. Every literacy area saw an increase in the proportion of students who had a teacher confident in teaching it. This was true across both grade three students and grade five students, and was most noticeable in the quality of ideas (writing), where grade three students saw an increase of the numbers of teachers expressing confidence from 48% to 71%.
Confidence in teaching literacy and teacher qualities
A regional scale focused on measuring teachers’ confidence in teaching literacy based on teachers’ responses was established. Higher scores on this scale indicate higher levels of confidence in teaching literacy. The literacy teaching confidence scores were analysed against teacher demographics (gender, age, teaching experience, and qualification level). The significant findings are listed below.
- Male teachers were significantly more confident in teaching literacy than female teachers.
- No significant difference in confidence teaching literacy was found based on the age, experience or qualifications of teachers.
- Overall, teachers in Papua New Guinea were more confident in teaching literacy compared to the average across the region.
Confidence in teaching numeracy
Table TT2.9 shows the percentage of students whose teachers expressed confidence in teaching numeracy topics.
Most students in both grade levels had teachers who were confident in teaching numeracy topics. In both grade levels, the proportion of students with confident teachers in the numeracy topics ranged between 71% and 95%, a slightly higher and narrower range than for literacy topics.
Across both grade levels, the topics where a lower proportion of students had teachers who expressed confidence were ‘Geometry’ (grade three, 73%; grade five, 83%) and ‘Data and chance’ (grade three, 71%; grade five, 81%).
Topics with the highest proportions of students whose teachers expressed confidence were: ‘Place value’ (grade three, 91%; grade five, 95%), ‘Numbers and patterns’ (grade three, 92%; grade five, 95%), and ‘Operations’ (grade three, 92%; grade five, 94%).
The same questions were asked of teachers in the 2018 PILNA cycle and results from both the 2018 and 2021 cycles of PILNA are presented for comparison in Table TT2.10. Similar findings were found in numeracy as in literacy. In every numeracy area, across both grade levels, a higher proportion of students had a teacher confident in teaching the areas in 2021 than in 2018.
Confidence in teaching numeracy and teacher characteristics
A regional scale with nine items focused on measuring teachers’ confidence in teaching numeracy based on teachers’ responses was established. Higher scores on this scale indicate higher levels of confidence in teaching numeracy. As with literacy, the numeracy teaching confidence scores were compared to teachers’ demographic groups (gender, age, teaching experience, highest qualification).
- Male teachers were significantly more confident in teaching numeracy than female teachers.
- No significant difference in confidence teaching numeracy was found based on the age, experience or qualifications of teachers.
- Overall, teachers in Papua New Guinea were more confident in teaching numeracy compared to the average across the region.
What does this mean?
A high proportion of students in Papua New Guinea have teachers who are confident in teaching literacy and numeracy. The proportion of students who have confident teachers was generally higher across the numeracy domain than the literacy domain.
In literacy, more students have confident teachers in areas that are structured or rule-based, such as spelling, punctuation and vocabulary. Fewer students have confident teachers in areas that require more subjective or complex teaching and assessment, such as quality of ideas and organisation and structure in writing.
Differences were noted within the comparisons for teacher demographic factors. Male teachers were significantly more confident in teaching literacy and numeracy than female teachers. However, age, teaching experience, and qualifications did not appear to have any effect on the confidence of teachers in literacy or numeracy.